Connect with us

Free For All

Dater’s Daily Links: Cale Makar likely to win Calder



Cale Makar

I know what a lot of you are thinking. Well, some of you anyway. “Shut up Dater, don’t proclaim Cale Makar the Calder Trophy winner, when we don’t know you. You just jinxed it.” 

I do have a long and illustrious career as a jinxer, a cooler, the modern-day male equivalent of Medusa, the snake-haired lady in Greek mythology whose eyes, if you looked into them, would turn you to stone. And let me be the first to say: If Cale Makar doesn’t win the Calder Trophy, this post will be deleted so fast it would make Medusa’s head spin (which supposedly it could do anyway).

Here’s a story: A few years ago, I think when we were in St. Louis at a hotel casino, Avalanche TV guy Marc Moser (then the radio guy) was on a roll at the blackjack table when I swung by to say hello. He was like a pig in slop, ecstatic over his winnings. I said, “OK then, well I better take off, because I’m a real cooler. Hope the winning continues.”

Moser laughed and said something like “No such thing as jinxes, stick around.” OK, I said, but I warned you.

He then proceeded to lose like eight hands in a row, all with me standing there watching. He shot me a dirty look and said, “OK, get out of here.”

But listen, I’m gonna say it anyway: I think Cale Makar is highly likely to win the Calder. Members of the Professional Hockey Writers Association had to turn in their ballots yesterday for voting on the major trophies we get to vote on (Hart, Norris, Selke, Calder, Lady Byng). We do not vote on the Vezina or the Jack Adams Award.

Superstreak Bonus!

Yes, I had a vote, and while I’m not gonna give it away as to who I voted for, I think this recent story might tip my hand a little.

Why do I think Makar will win the Calder for NHL rookie of the year? Well, because I’ve asked several other voters who they picked, and every single one of them chose Makar too, over Vancouver’s Quinn Hughes. Pierre LeBrun of TSN also polled some top hockey people about who they’d pick – Makar or Hughes – and Makar was the choice in 10 of the 11 people polled.

I still think the voting might be close. Hughes has some good support, especially, it seems, from media north of the border. But I think Makar’s got this.

If he wins, he’ll join Chris Drury, Gabe Landeskog and Nathan MacKinnon as players from the Avs to have done so. Not bad for a team that’s been around for only 25 years. Peter Forsberg won the Calder in 1994, but he was a Nordique then.

Some Tuesday links on this, the sixteenth of June in the year of our Lord, 2020:

  • Canada will close its border another 30 days, until July 21, because of the virus. But, contrary to assumption (including mine), that doesn’t appear to be a death knell for Canadian cities hoping to become a hub for the playoffs, as the Toronto Star’s Kevin McGran explains (Toronto Star)
  • Jason Botterill was fired today as GM of the Sabres. Columnist Mike Harrington said the move was long overdue (Buffalo News)
  • Newspapers are having a hard enough time these days. Getting major stuff wrong, and having to apologize to an NHL team owner about it, doesn’t help (Hockey News)
  • Bettman did a visit with ESPN last night, and said virus protocol will be very strict in the playoffs (
  • Gabe Landeskog supposedly will do a Zoom call with us local media today. I’ll obviously do something on that here if it happens.
Subscribe to CHN+ today!

Adrian Dater - Kiss and Larry Bird fan. Writer with @Gambling and @Bookies, Avs Insider with 104.3 The Fan. Denver Post, SI, Bleacher Report alum, author of seven books.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

15 of the 18 writers that polled in their last poll chose Makar also: A panel of 18 writers believe Makar will win the Calder this season. In fact, Makar had the most first-place votes and points of the five Trophy Tracker stories produced by The 21-year-old right-handed shot received 15 first-place votes and 86 points in the poll, the most he’s accrued at any point this season. Hughes earned two first-place votes (73 points). “I would also have Makar a notch ahead … Colorado has dealt with a lot of injuries too,” said Craig Button,… Read more »


I said this elsewhere. What stands out for me about Makar are 2 things:

1) At one point during the season, he was in a legitimate albeit brief race for consideration for the Norris. You can’t say that about Hughes.
2) You can’t give Makar enough credit for not letting the absence due to injury derail his season. Few players that miss substantial portions of the season due to injury end up winning awards like the Norris, Calder or Hart – see McDavid.

Charles-Edouard Boivin

I don’t know which canadian media you get your source from but let me tell you I didn’t read any article favoring anyone but Makar – I live in Canada 🇨🇦

Colorado's premier coverage of the Avalanche from professional hockey people. Adrian Dater, Editor-in-Chief. Part of the National Hockey Now family.

This site is in no way associated with the Colorado Avalanche or the NHL. Copyright © 2019 National Hockey Now and Adrian Dater.