Connect with us


Avs Game 5 Grades: Pain.



Avs lose Game 5 against Vegas

Brandon Saad (B) – Brandon Saad continues to lead the charge for the Avalanche. That’s exactly what he was brought to Denver for. He’s that veteran presence that is a requisite of the NHL playoffs. He scores his seventh goal of the playoffs tonight, and now has six goals in his last seven games. He was also credited with two giveaways though.

Nathan MacKinnon (B-) – MacKinnon looked like a man possessed tonight. That’s the Nathan MacKinnon the Avalanche have been missing for much of the series against Vegas. He was cutting through the ice, makings plays, creating chances, winning a good majority of his face-offs. It just wasn’t good enough tonight though. Like his new linemate, MacKinnon was also credited with two giveaways.

Mikko Rantanen (B-) – Was *this* close to scoring in the first period, and then seconds later was penalized for interference for “kicking” the stick of Marc-Andre Fleury. Not so sure about that one, stripes. But the game goes on. The Avs couldn’t buy a power play tonight.

Gabe Landeskog (C+) – I really liked his line tonight. Landeskog was leading the way in the physicality department (team-leading 8 hits tonight) and the led the forwards in ice time, too. He finished with a -2. Landeskog is now -5 in the last three games of this series. The most costly “minus” was his giveaway that led to the Knights’ tying goal.

J.T. Compher (B+) – J.T. Compher had a great game tonight. I’ve haven’t said that statement very often this postseason. I think putting Compher with Landeskog was a great idea. Compher needs a guy like Landeskog to lead the reins a bit I think. Compher was generating chances all night long and nearly ended the damn thing 10 seconds in OT.

“That’s the margin in these playoffs,” Landeskog said of Compher’s near-goal after the game.

Val Nichushkin (B+) – Big Val played a heavy, heavy game tonight. He had his legs under him too. He led the team with five shots on goal tonight. On the defensive side of things, he was the Avs best forward. He chipped in five hits and two takeaways.

Logan O’Connor (A-) – Man, I’ve missed Logan O’Connor. I say it just about every time I watch him play, but the kid’s all-heart. And I say it so often because he’s that consistent. He’s that boost of energy the Avalanche need in the postseason. Someone who not only finishes all of his checks, but seeks them out. It’s a damn shame he wasn’t around for the whole Vegas series. This could’ve been a different series. I’m telling you, he can be that much of a difference-maker.

Tyson Jost (A) – Was *this* to making SportsCenter Top-10 with his trot to the net early in the second period, inches away from giving the Avs a 2-0 lead. But alas. That’s the margin in these playoffs. 

I thought, overall, Tyson Jost played a great game. He kicked it into high-gear tonight and was generating chances most every shift.

Andre Burakovsky (C-) – A brutal giveaway early in the third cut the Avs lead to 2-1. It surely swung the momentum in the direction of Vegas, no doubt. But he wasn’t the only one turning pucks over tonight.

Either way, Burakovsky is a guy that hasn’t impressed me much this series—or, really, for a good portion of the postseason, for that matter. He’s turned over a lot of pucks so far, and Colorado’s needed his depth scoring this playoffs, and he’s fallen short.

$20 Dollar Bonus Voucher!

Alex Newhook (C) – Alex Newhook now has five points and is a +6 in his first dozen National Hockey League games. He’s not there yet, but Newhook has the ability to be a mainstay, top-six center for this Avalanche team for a long, long time. He’s looked better than average in every game he’s played in his young career. Newhook played just over six minutes tonight, and I wouldn’t exactly say he was a difference-maker in tonight’s game.

P-E Bellemare (C) – He made a couple of nice shot blocks, in what I’d say is a vintage Bellemare game. That is to say, he’s blocking shots, making smart plays, nothing flashy, but subtly important. He played few minutes but certainly pulled his weight tonight.

Joonas Donskoi (B-) – Joonas Donskoi was the beneficiary of great sustained O-zone pressure by his line late in the second period to put the Avs up 2-0. That newly-formed fourth line was pretty solid all night long. I thought Donskoi played with good pace tonight, too.


Devon Toews (B+) – He finished with a team-leading +2, five takeaways, and assist and a couple shots on goal in 25 minutes of ice time. I thought he was activating and pushing the pace throughout the night.

Cale Makar (B) – One of the messages preached during the Avs come-to-Jesus team meeting after getting thoroughly out-worked by Vegas in Game 3 was for the D to help out their offense and activate more. What Cale Makar did tonight was all of that. He was flying and making plays left and right. He generated three shots on goal, but finishes with a team-leading three giveaways, as well.

Ryan Graves (C-) – Tough break on the OT-winner for Ryan Graves. He had both of his shot attempts blocked, leading to the game-winning Mark Stone breakaway less than a minute into overtime.

Sam Girard (C-) – I haven’t been exactly impressed with Sam Girard’s play these past few games. He’s been relatively quiet and not as involved in the game as I’d like to see, seemingly frantic and indecisive with the puck. Tonight, I thought he ramped up his physical play a bit at least. He led the backend with five hits.

Patrik Nemeth (C-) – Wasn’t his worse game, by far, in the series. Nemeth picks up his first point of the postseason, and, believe it or not, he’s a +3 in the playoffs.

Conor Timmins (C+) – I love the confidence that Conor Timmins is playing with recently, especially on such a big stage. He’s holding onto the puck more, not afraid to stickhandle a little more, he’s making crisp accurate, patient passes. Keep it up, kid.

Philipp Grubauer (C) – It certainly wasn’t Grubauer’s best game by any means. His glove was too slow on Mark Stone’s snipe, but his teammates hung him out to dry for Vegas’ first two goals.

Subscribe to CHN+ today!

A graduate of the University of Colorado Boulder, Scott has so far spent the early parts of his young career covering Colorado hockey — from the Avalanche to the Colorado Eagles to the DU Pioneers. His work can be found across sites such as, and SB Nation, among others. Scott currently resides in the Capitol Hill neighborhood of Denver, where he works as a Marketing Executive when he's not writing.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Spencer Bradshaw

I gotta give Burakovsky an F. Absolutely brutal turnover after having more than enough time to get the puck out of the zone. The guy can be such a defensive liability.

chippy play

Remember when he used to be a sniper?


Where do I start with these bizarre grades: Compher – D+. Never gets it done. Missed a golden opportunity to win the game with a half open net on the right side and an uncontested shot. His nickname should be “Almost.” Sam Girard – C+. Actually played a much stronger game and didn’t get rag-dolled like the previous games. Trade bait as far as I’m concerned. Nice, puck moving defenseman in the regular season. Becomes a Pee-Wee player in the playoffs where he can’t move your grandmother from the front of the net and gets muscled out in the corners… Read more »

Aaron Hinton

Rico Suave, I always enjoy reading your thoughts but this was your all-time best, well said!


Agree! Well done! Maybe an F for the coach – we are being out coached – Vegas is not just strong on the puck, they know exactly where our outlet passing will be and our O-zone tendencies are – we are not adjusting and are way too predictable.

Richard Trujillo

Bednar’s moves were brilliant. Everything he did worked perfectly and the TEAM responded. A select few individuals that the team is depending on (how any of those guys have a grade higher than a D- is beyond me) have let everyone down for the 4th consecutive year.


Dude get out of my head! I have posted similar things on other apps and your reaction is so on point. This grading was like a piece written on the team site, who are you afraid of offending Scott?

Brenda Logan

pretty biased review. AVs were just outplayed. insinuating bad calls or “doubtful” calling at least…”couldn’t by a powerplay” no but even their acting couldn’t sneak one in… both played well…Vegas played better

chippy play

Refs swallowed their whistles except for one ticky-tack call against Rantanen.

DeBoer’s whining earlier in the series worked, as it often does for coaches. I hate that and it’s embarrassing for the league that it works, but I guess Bednar should do the same.

Scott Smith

Graves didnt have a tough break on the blocked shot, he didnt look up once after the first block if he did he would of seen Makar wide open at the opposite faceoff circle, may not of scored but it would of saved the Stone Breakaway which is not Grubauer’s fault

chippy play

Yep, it was lazy, selfish and dumb.



Aaron Hinton

I still think we are going to pull this off in 7.

Colorado's premier coverage of the Avalanche from professional hockey people. Adrian Dater, Editor-in-Chief. Part of the National Hockey Now family.

This site is in no way associated with the Colorado Avalanche or the NHL. Copyright © 2019 National Hockey Now and Adrian Dater.