Connect with us

Colorado Avalanche

Cale Makar Gets Shafted in Norris Trophy Vote



NHL Trade

For me, it wasn’t too close. Cale Makar was the only logical choice to win the Norris Trophy as the NHL’s best all-around defenseman this season. But I didn’t have a vote.

Neither did a lot of people. For whatever reason, the list of voters for the NHL trophies was drastically cut down this year. Only 100 writers got votes. Anyway, Makar would have gotten my first-place vote. Makar, for me, was better in all the major categories. But there was one thing that hurt him: he missed 12 games to injury. Adam Fox of the New York Rangers, who won the award, missed only one game on the season.

But Makar had only three fewer points (47-44) than Fox. Makar had three more goals (8-5) than Fox. Makar had more than double the number of hits (49-23) in 12 fewer games than Fox. Fox did block many more shots than Makar (102-36), but you know what they say about blocked shots; If you don’t have the puck much, you have to block more shots.

Makar had far better Corsi numbers than Fox. His Corsi for percentage was a tremendous 65.5. Fox’s Corsi for percentage: 53.1. Fox was a plus-19, Makar a plus-17. Makar had only one fewer power-play point (23-22) in 12 fewer games.

Makar played on a team that had the best record in the regular season. Fox played for a Rangers team that missed the playoffs.

$20 Dollar Bonus Voucher!

I try not to get too worked up over hometown players and trophies, but Makar clearly got the shaft here. It’ll be interesting to see how many eastern reporters got votes as opposed to western ones. Adam Fox is a good player. But Cale Makar is much better, and should have won the Norris.

Here was the final vote:

Five members of the PHWA did not even have Makar in their top 5 for the trophy. What an embarrassment for the PHWA.

Subscribe to CHN+ today!

Adrian Dater - Kiss and Larry Bird fan. Writer with @Gambling and @Bookies, Avs Insider with 104.3 The Fan. Denver Post, SI, Bleacher Report alum, author of seven books.

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

I love Makar, but I don’t think you can be shafted for any award when you miss 21% of the season. Fox had a lot of tough defensive assignments and didn’t have Makar’s team depth helping him out. If Cale plays 90% of the games next season and puts up close to a point a game again with good defensive numbers, yes, he’ll be getting shafted if he doesn’t win, but I think it’s amazing that he finished ahead of Hedman this year. Now to get him resigned without breaking the bank…


Cale doesn’t play in New York, hence less media coverage and less media appreciation.
He was absolutely robbed, by the same media bias that we’ve seen for years.


Unfortunate, but…New York, New York…I’m In A New York State of Mind…not…Rocky Mountain High…and he’s young…and they didn’t go any deeper…as hh5 notes, at this juncture the concern is getting the contract resolved…

The PG

I’ll never understand the injury argument used as a negative when their numbers are comparable. Makar had 12 less games and their numbers, comparatively speaking, are even! How does that hurt him? Makes no sense.

Colorado's premier coverage of the Avalanche from professional hockey people. Adrian Dater, Editor-in-Chief. Part of the National Hockey Now family.

This site is in no way associated with the Colorado Avalanche or the NHL. Copyright © 2019 National Hockey Now and Adrian Dater.